SG2 vs VG10 Comparison (Which Is The Better Knife Steel?)

Sharing is caring!

When it comes to knife steel, there are seemingly infinite options to choose from.

Back in the day when I was saving up to buy an Old Timer knife from my local Ace Hardware, I had no idea how many options or how complicated the choice could be.

But, does it have to be? Is all of the hype about new super steels simply marketing?

Well, in many cases, yes. However, SG2 and VG10 are two extremely popular knife steels that have some key differences that you’ll want to learn about if you’re in the knife market.

So let’s do an SG2 vs VG10 comparison and see which one you should pick in your next knife! That is assuming that the same knife is available in both steels. In my opinion, knife choice trumps steel choice.

Having said that, let’s take a look at how SG2 and VG10 compare in factors such as toughness, edge retention, ease of sharpening, cost, and more!

Background & Overview Of Each Steel

SG2

SG2 is a high-carbon, high-performance powder metallurgy (PM) stainless steel, with a carbon content between 1.25% and 1.45%. Originally developed in Japan, it’s engineered for cutting applications where wear resistance, edge retention, and sharpness matter most.

Despite the occasional myth tying it to traditional swordmaking, SG2 is a modern steel—also known as R2—produced using a powder metallurgy process. This technique creates a fine-grained microstructure with evenly distributed carbides, which translates to excellent cutting performance and improved toughness compared to many traditional stainless steels.

SG2 is most commonly found in high-end Japanese kitchen knives, where its hardness (61–64 HRC) and superb edge retention shine. You’re unlikely to see it in pocket knives or general EDC tools—partly due to cost and partly because its performance advantages are most appreciated in culinary use.

It offers great edge retention, good corrosion resistance, and surprising ease of sharpening for a steel in this class—though it can be slightly more brittle than softer steels if abused.

VG10

VG10 is a high-carbon stainless steel created by Takefu Special Steel Co., Ltd. in the early 1990s. It was designed to offer a balance of sharpness, edge retention, corrosion resistance, and ease of maintenance—making it a go-to choice for many knife makers, particularly for kitchen and EDC blades.

Its typical composition includes:

• Carbon: ~1.0%
• Chromium: ~15.0%
• Cobalt: ~1.5%
• Vanadium: ~0.2%
• Molybdenum: ~1.0%
• Manganese, Silicon: trace amounts

The inclusion of cobalt boosts hardness and edge stability, while vanadium forms hard carbides that contribute to wear resistance. VG10 is often heat treated to around 60–61 HRC, which gives it a good balance of hardness and toughness without making it difficult to sharpen.

VG10’s corrosion resistance is one of its standout features, making it well-suited for humid kitchens or outdoor environments. It has become one of the most popular mid-to-high-end stainless steels used in knives today, frequently appearing in brands like Spyderco, Mcusta, and many Japanese kitchen knife lines.

SG2 vs VG10

Toughness

Toughness is an essential quality in any knife steel—it refers to how well the steel resists chipping, cracking, or breaking under stress, especially when encountering bone, hard veggies, or accidental drops.

A tougher steel doesn’t necessarily mean it holds an edge longer—that’s a different property (wear resistance). In fact, some ultra-hard steels can be brittle, making toughness a balancing act in steel design.

Now here’s where it gets interesting: despite being a powder metallurgy steel, SG2 actually has slightly better toughness than VG10 in lab testing. Its fine-grained microstructure, thanks to the PM process, allows it to resist microfractures and chipping a bit more effectively.

That said, both SG2 and VG10 are stainless steels, and while they’re not on the same toughness level as tool steels like 5160 or CPM-3V, they’re more than adequate for kitchen use and light outdoor tasks. You’ll want to avoid prying or batoning with either, but they’ll both handle normal use with no problem.

So for overall toughness is this comparison:

Winner: VG10

Hardness

Hardness is one of the key factors that influences how well a knife holds its edge—and how long it stays sharp between sharpening sessions. It’s typically measured on the Rockwell Hardness Scale (HRC), and higher numbers generally mean better edge retention (though not always better overall performance).

Steel hardness comes from carbon content and the way the steel is processed. More carbon generally means more carbides, which are hard compounds that boost wear resistance. But there’s a catch: too many carbides—or poorly distributed ones—can make steel more brittle. That’s why manufacturers need to strike a balance between hardness and toughness, depending on the intended use of the knife.

In our comparison, SG2 clearly takes the lead in hardness. With 1.25–1.45% carbon and a fine-grained microstructure from its powder metallurgy (PM) process, SG2 is typically hardened to 61–64 HRC. That puts it in the realm of true high-performance steels, offering excellent edge retention and clean slicing capability.

VG10, on the other hand, is no slouch. It usually lands in the 60–61 HRC range, which is still more than adequate for most kitchen and EDC knives. It gives up a little edge retention compared to SG2 but tends to be a bit more forgiving during sharpening.

So if maximum hardness and longevity between sharpening sessions are your priorities:

Winner: SG2 (barely)

Sharpening & Edge Retention

This is where trade-offs get real. SG2 has the upper hand in edge retention, thanks not only to its higher hardness but also to its fine, evenly distributed carbides from the powder metallurgy process. That means it can stay sharp longer—especially with fine edge grinds often seen in Japanese kitchen knives.

But that edge retention comes at a cost: SG2 can take a bit more time and effort to sharpen, especially if you’re using traditional whetstones or ceramic rods. It’s not impossible to sharpen—just a little more stubborn. Diamond stones or guided systems can make the job easier.

VG10, by comparison, sharpens more easily. Its slightly lower hardness (typically 60–61 HRC) and more forgiving structure mean it responds faster to stones. You can usually touch it up quickly and get back to work, which is nice if you prefer easy maintenance over max longevity.

If you hate sharpening and want your edge to last as long as possible: SG2 is the winner.
If you prefer a knife that’s easy to maintain and touch up regularly: VG10 has the edge.

Bottom line?

Winner: Tie — depends on your sharpening style and patience.

Cost

Let’s be honest: SG2 knives can be a wallet punch. They’re often significantly more expensive than their VG10 counterparts—and not just because the steel itself costs more. SG2 is mostly used in high-end Japanese knives, where the price reflects not only the materials but the overall craftsmanship: think layered Damascus cladding, artisan heat treatment, and premium handles.

VG10, meanwhile, shows up in everything from mass-produced kitchen knives to mid-range pocket knives. It’s easier to work with during manufacturing, more widely available, and often found in blades that are more budget-friendly, without necessarily feeling cheap.

That said, price ≠ value. SG2 knives often justify their cost with exceptional performance, fine finishes, and attention to detail. If you’re looking for a lifelong kitchen tool and love sharpening less often, the price may be worth it. But if you want solid performance at a more accessible price point, VG10 delivers a lot of bang for the buck.

Winner: VG10 (for most people)

Overall

At the end of the day, I lean toward SG2 in my own kitchen. I love how long it holds an edge, and I don’t mind putting in a little more effort when it’s time to sharpen. For me, the performance—and let’s be honest, the craftsmanship in most SG2 knives—is worth the extra cost.

That said, if I were recommending a knife to a friend who just wants something reliable, easy to maintain, and affordable, I’d probably point them toward VG10. It’s a great all-around steel that punches above its weight in most categories.

So here’s my advice: don’t just compare specs—think about how you actually use your knives. Are you cooking every night and want a long-lasting workhorse? SG2 might be for you. Just need a solid, easy-care blade? VG10 will serve you well.

Either way, you’re not making a bad choice.