Is CPM MagnaCut a Good Knife Steel? Pros & Cons

Sharing is caring!

When you visit a merchant by clicking a link on this site we may make a commission on anything you buy (at no additional cost to you).   Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to Amazon Associates and the eBay Partner Network.”

At A Glance
CPM MagnaCut, developed by Larrin Thomas and produced by Crucible Industries in 2021, is considered a superior knife steel due to its balance of edge retention, toughness, and corrosion resistance. Its innovative composition lowers chromium content compared to other stainless steels, resulting in enhanced performance characteristics. This fine-grained, stainless steel achieves the toughness of CPM-4V and the corrosion resistance of CPM-20CV, offering impressive edge retention due to high wear resistance. Despite its somewhat challenging sharpening process, it is applauded for its versatility across various knife applications. Its properties and balanced characteristics make it a preferred choice among knife makers and users, surpassing many popular stainless and non-stainless steels.

CPM MagnaCut, developed by renowned steel author Larrin Thomas and produced by Crucible Industries in 2021, is gaining attention in the knife-making industry for its unique design and performance characteristics. This groundbreaking material aims to reduce the chromium content in its composition, allowing for the dissolution of available chromium carbides during heat treatment. The result is a fine microstructure that makes sharpening more manageable than other steels of similar wear resistance.

One of the primary reasons CPM MagnaCut is considered an excellent knife steel is its balance of edge retention, toughness, and corrosion resistance. This unique combination of properties sets it apart from other stainless steels, which typically have between 14 and 20% chromium content. By reducing chromium levels, CPM MagnaCut presents improved performance characteristics desirable in knife making.

In summary, CPM MagnaCut is considered one of the best all-around knife steels available today. Its innovative composition and manufacturing process give it an edge over other materials in terms of its overall performance, making it a popular choice for those seeking a high-quality and durable knife steel.

CPM Magnacut Overview

CPM Magnacut is a breakthrough knife steel developed by Crucible Industries, recognized for its exceptional balance of toughness, edge retention, and corrosion resistance. This powder metallurgy stainless steel has been specifically created for use in knifemaking and offers a unique combination of qualities not found in other stainless steels.

The development of CPM Magnacut was influenced by the research of Dr. Larrin Thomas, a metallurgist who sought to create a steel with high chromium content for corrosion resistance and vanadium for wear resistance. As a result, CPM Magnacut exhibits the toughness of CPM-4V, which is a hard-use steel found on high-end fixed blades, and the stainlessness of CPM-20CV, a tried-and-true premium knife steel used mainly in folders.

One of the key advantages of CPM Magnacut is its excellent edge retention, which is attributed to its high wear resistance. However, this characteristic might make it a bit challenging to sharpen. CPM Magnacut is produced by Niagara Specialty Metals, a company that has a long history in the metallurgy industry and is partnered with Crucible Industries.

The development of Magnacut was also influenced by the contributions of Vanadium Alloys Steel Company (VASCO) and Knife Steel Nerds, which provided valuable insights into the selection of materials and performance of the steel. With its exceptional balance of properties, CPM Magnacut has quickly become popular among both knifemakers and users, showcasing its value in the knifemaking industry.

Chemical Composition

CPM MagnaCut steel is a high-performance stainless steel designed specifically for knife making. The alloy boasts an impressive balance of toughness, edge retention, and corrosion resistance, making it a popular choice for various types of knives.

The chemical composition of MagnaCut steel contains a blend of elements that contribute to its unique properties. The steel is made using powder metallurgy, a process that ensures a fine, uniform grain structure, and enhanced performance. The primary elements in CPM MagnaCut include:

  • Carbon: Carbon plays a crucial role in giving steel its strength and hardness. MagnaCut features a moderate carbon content that strikes a balance between toughness and edge retention.
  • Chromium: The defining characteristic of stainless steel is its chromium content, which provides corrosion resistance. MagnaCut has around 14% Chromium, which offers excellent corrosion resistance without compromising other properties.
  • Molybdenum: This element enhances the strength and hardenability of the steel, as well as its resistance to wear and abrasion.
  • Vanadium: Vanadium helps in grain refinement, resulting in improved toughness and edge retention in the MagnaCut steel.
  • Tungsten: Though present in small amounts, Tungsten contributes to the overall hardness and wear resistance of the steel.
  • Niobium: Niobium is an essential component that helps improve edge retention and wear resistance by forming hard carbides in the steel matrix.
  • Nitrogen: MagnaCut contains nitrogen, which not only enhances the corrosion resistance but also contributes to increased hardness.

With this combination of elements, CPM MagnaCut delivers a high level of performance across various knife applications. Its chemical composition allows it to achieve the toughness of CPM-4V steel and the corrosion resistance of CPM-20CV, making it an excellent choice for knife enthusiasts and professionals alike.

Properties of CPM Magnacut

Hardness and Toughness

CPM Magnacut steel is known for its impressive combination of hardness and toughness. The hardness of a knife steel determines its ability to resist deformation, while toughness measures the resistance to fracturing. CPM Magnacut achieves a high level of hardness due to its fine microstructure, which also contributes to its toughness. In comparison to other knife steels, CPM Magnacut has the toughness of CPM-4V, a hard-use steel found in high-end fixed blades, making it suitable for demanding applications.

Wear Resistance

Another important property of CPM Magnacut steel is its wear resistance. This feature is vital for maintaining a sharp edge on knives during long-term use. The CPM Magnacut steel composition includes Carbon, which increases edge retention, hardness, and tensile strength, ultimately boosting its wear and abrasion resistance. In contrast, 14C28N, a popular stainless steel for knives, might not rival CPM Magnacut in wear resistance.

Corrosion Resistance

Stainless steels such as CPM Magnacut achieve corrosion resistance by the addition of chromium. Corrosion resistance is a crucial factor for knife users, as it helps avoid rust over time. Although CPM Magnacut steel has reduced chromium carbides compared to other stainless steels, it compensates by enhancing corrosion resistance properties. CPM Magnacut has stainlessness comparable to CPM-20CV, a premium knife steel used primarily in folding knives. Overall, this steel offers a balanced set of properties that are highly desirable in knife construction.

Comparison with Other Knife Steels

CPM Magnacut vs Stainless Steels

CPM Magnacut is a relatively new stainless steel that offers a unique combination of properties, such as corrosion resistance, toughness, and edge retention. When compared to other popular stainless steels, CPM Magnacut stands out in several aspects.

For example, S30V and S35VN are two well-known stainless steels that are commonly used in knives for their good balance of edge retention and corrosion resistance. However, CPM Magnacut surpasses them in terms of toughness and edge retention while maintaining comparable corrosion resistance. It is also important to note that the addition of vanadium in S35VN improves on S30V’s properties slightly, but not enough to outperform CPM Magnacut in overall performance.

Another stainless steel often used in knife making is M390, which is known for its outstanding corrosion resistance and excellent edge retention. While it’s true that M390 exhibits these qualities, CPM Magnacut still manages to provide a better balance of toughness, edge retention, and corrosion resistance, making it a more suitable choice for users who prioritize these traits in their knives.

CPM Magnacut vs Non-Stainless Steels

Comparing CPM Magnacut to non-stainless steels, such as CPM 4V, CPM 3V, CPM CruWear, and 420HC, reveals even more significant differences.

CPM 4V and CPM 3V are both high toughness tool steels that sacrifice some corrosion resistance for increased toughness. Although they perform well in terms of edge retention, their corrosion resistance is lower than that of CPM Magnacut. This makes CPM Magnacut a more versatile option, especially for those who need a knife that can withstand various environmental conditions without rusting.

CruWear, on the other hand, is a semi-stainless steel that provides a balance between toughness and edge retention, similar to CPM 4V and CPM 3V. Nonetheless, CPM Magnacut’s unique chemical composition allows it to offer even superior edge retention and toughness, along with better corrosion resistance than CruWear.

When considering 420HC, a lower-end stainless steel, it falls short in many aspects compared to CPM Magnacut. While 420HC is easier to sharpen and more affordable, its edge retention, toughness, and corrosion resistance are notably lower than what CPM Magnacut has to offer.

In summary, CPM Magnacut presents a noteworthy advancement in the world of knife steels. Its performance exceeds that of many popular stainless and non-stainless steels, making it an excellent choice for those looking for a versatile, high-performing knife steel.

Applications of CPM Magnacut

CPM Magnacut is a versatile knife steel that has earned a reputation for its excellent balance of properties, making it suitable for various applications. One of the most popular uses for this steel is in the manufacturing of kitchen knives. Thanks to its fine microstructure, Magnacut is able to provide exceptional edge retention, ensuring that the knife remains sharp even after extensive use.

In addition to kitchen knives, Magnacut has found its place in the world of knifemaking due to its characteristics such as wear resistance, toughness, and corrosion resistance. Powder metallurgy stainless steel ensures a well-rounded performance in edge retention and impact resistance, which are essential factors when creating high-quality knives.

When it comes to intended use, CPM Magnacut is an ideal choice for both small folders and big choppers. Its impressive ability to withstand impact and maintain a sharp cut makes it a popular choice among knife enthusiasts and professionals alike. This steel’s toughness levels are comparable to non-stainless steels like CPM 3V, which further showcases its versatile nature.

The balance in properties of CPM Magnacut steel is a noticeable advantage. With its great edge retention and superb toughness, it manages to provide excellent performance without sacrificing other essential qualities. This makes Magnacut a go-to choice for many knife makers and users looking for an all-around performer.

In conclusion, the applications of CPM Magnacut are diverse and cover a wide range of uses. From kitchen knives to various cutting tools, this steel provides exceptional performance and finds its place in many aspects of knifemaking.

Metallurgical Aspects

Carbides and Microstructure

CPM MagnaCut steel, created through powder metallurgy, is known for its unique microstructure composition, resulting in improved knife performance. Its carbide content features a balanced combination of chromium carbides, vanadium carbides, and niobium carbides. Chromium carbides boost corrosion resistance, while niobium and vanadium carbides contribute to wear resistance and overall toughness.

The powder metallurgy process used by Crucible Industries helps minimize carbide segregation, lending a fine and uniform carbide distribution for consistent performance. Compared to conventionally-forged knife steels, CPM MagnaCut exhibits a more refined microstructure, which in turn enhances its cutting ability and edge retention characteristics.

Role of Alloying Elements

Several key alloying elements within CPM MagnaCut contribute to its outstanding metallurgical properties. Chromium, which forms chromium carbides, offers excellent corrosion resistance, a typical concern in knife steel. Furthermore, vanadium and niobium, essential in forming vanadium carbides and niobium carbide, work synergistically to improve wear resistance and toughness.

The well-rounded performance of CPM MagnaCut can also be attributed to its balance of alloying elements. By fine-tuning the chromium content without compromising strength and wear resistance, CPM MagnaCut effectively surpasses the performance of other popular knife steels, such as AEB-L, LC200N, and Vanadis 4 Extra. The result is a knife steel that boasts a unique combination of toughness, corrosion resistance, and edge retention.

Overall, the metallurgical aspects of CPM MagnaCut steel, including its distinct carbide and microstructure composition and the crucial role of its alloying elements, render it a top choice for many applications requiring high-performance knife steel.

Edge Geometry and Stability

CPM MagnaCut steel is known for its impressive balance of toughness, edge retention, and corrosion resistance, making it an ideal choice for knife steel. It is important to consider edge geometry and stability when evaluating knife steels, as these factors can greatly influence performance in various cutting tasks.

One of the key advantages of CPM MagnaCut is its fine microstructure, which contributes to enhanced edge stability. Fine microstructures are less prone to chipping or rolling, allowing for the creation of thinner, sharper edges that maintain their cutting ability for longer periods of time. This means that knives made from MagnaCut can be designed with a variety of edge geometries to suit the specific cutting needs of users.

Although high-performance steels like CPM MagnaCut are not considered brittle, they offer a good balance of toughness and wear resistance. This balance is essential for edge stability, as a brittle steel could chip or break under stress, while a very tough steel might not hold an edge as well. MagnaCut strikes the right balance, providing a durable and reliable cutting edge that can withstand demanding tasks without the risk of chipping or degradation.

In terms of corrosion resistance, CPM MagnaCut excels at resisting rust and is well-suited for use in saltwater environments. Its high chromium content and advanced powder metallurgy manufacturing process provide a stainless steel that holds up well against corrosion in wet or humid conditions. This makes MagnaCut an excellent choice for fishermen, divers, and others who need a reliable knife in saltwater situations.

In summary, the edge geometry and stability of knives made from CPM MagnaCut steel make it a versatile and reliable choice for many different applications. With exceptional edge retention, toughness, and corrosion resistance, MagnaCut provides the performance that knife users can rely on for various cutting needs, both on land and in saltwater environments.

When you visit a merchant by clicking a link on this site we may make a commission on anything you buy (at no additional cost to you).   Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to Amazon Associates and the eBay Partner Network.”