When you visit a merchant by clicking a link on this site we may make a commission on anything you buy (at no additional cost to you). Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to Amazon Associates and the eBay Partner Network.”
At A Glance
S45VN, an evolution of the popular S35VN and S30V steels, is recognized for its robust toughness and excellent edge retention due to its high carbon and vanadium content. On the other hand, Magnacut, a recent introduction by Crucible Industries, is lauded for its remarkable balance of corrosion resistance, toughness, and edge retention, with the unique addition of Nitrogen contributing to its superior corrosion resistance. While S45VN is ideally suited for general-purpose knives, Magnacut stands out for knives designed for high-stress tasks. The choice between these two steels will depend on the knife’s intended use and the user’s preference.
Top Rated Knives
S45VN
When selecting the ideal knife, blade steel is a paramount factor to consider. In the knife-making sphere, S45VN and Magnacut are two renowned blade steels often contrasted due to their diverse properties. This article aims to analyze and compare S45VN and Magnacut in aspects of their composition, hardness, toughness, corrosion resistance, edge retention, and ease of sharpening, thereby helping you determine the perfect fit for your knife.
In the labyrinthine realm of knife-making materials, it is easy to get overwhelmed, especially for those unfamiliar with the subject.
To assist in unscrambling this complex field, we will probe an in-depth comparison between two widely acclaimed knife steel types: S45VN and Magnacut. Our comparison will focus on their composition, hardness, toughness, corrosion resistance, edge retention, and ease of sharpening.
Steel Background
To set the stage for the comparison, it is vital to comprehend the nature of each steel type and their production process.
S45VN
S45VN is an evolution of the popular S35VN and S30V steels, designed by Crucible Industries to provide improved toughness and edge retention. As an exceptional grade knife steel, S45VN utilizes a powdered metallurgy construction to ensure a fine grain and highly homogenous steel.
Magnacut
Introduced by Crucible Industries, Magnacut is a newer player in the blade steel industry. Known for its superb balance of corrosion resistance, toughness, and edge retention, Magnacut offers versatility and performance, making it a popular choice among knife makers and enthusiasts.
Steel Composition
Our first comparison point is the chemical composition of each steel.
S45VN
- Carbon: 1.48%
- Chromium: 16%
- Molybdenum: 1%
- Vanadium: 4%
- Niobium: .5%
- Silicon: .3%
Magnacut
- Carbon: 1.15%
- Chromium: 14%
- Molybdenum: 1%
- Vanadium: 4%
- Nitrogen: .15%
- Manganese: .45%
- Nickel: 0.5%
- Silicon: .45%
The composition above illustrates that S45VN possesses more Carbon but the same amount of Vanadium as Magnacut, contributing to its superior hardness and edge retention. In contrast, the unique addition of Nitrogen in Magnacut enhances its corrosion resistance.
S45VN vs Magnacut – Complete Comparison
Hardness
The hardness of the knife steel directly impacts its wear resistance and edge retention.
S45VN exhibits a Rockwell hardness (HRC) of 59-62, marking a high level of hardness that contributes to excellent edge retention. It manages to balance hardness and toughness, reducing the risk of chipping or breaking under intense use.
Magnacut has a Rockwell hardness (HRC) of 60-62, signifying its similar hardness level to S45VN. It offers excellent wear resistance and retains an edge remarkably well, even under rigorous use.
Toughness
Toughness indicates a steel’s capacity to resist chips and cracks under use.
S45VN is a very tough steel, capable of withstanding high-stress usage. It is a suitable choice for knives that demand durability and high resilience.
Magnacut also offers high toughness, on par with, if not superior to S45VN. This resilience is a key feature of Magnacut and is why it’s favored in knives that undergo high-stress tasks.
Corrosion Resistance
The corrosion resistance of steel determines its ability to resist rust and oxidation.
S45VN, with a 16% Chromium content, presents impressive corrosion resistance, making it a suitable choice for knives used in humid or wet conditions.
Magnacut, despite having lower Chromium content (14%) than S45VN, demonstrates exceptional corrosion resistance due to the presence of Nitrogen. It surpasses many other steels, including S45VN, in this aspect.
Ease of Sharpening
The ease of sharpening signifies how simply a steel can be honed using typical methods.
S45VN, despite its high hardness, is surprisingly easy to sharpen. Although achieving a razor-sharp edge may demand some effort, it offers a reasonable balance between edge retention and sharpening ease.
Magnacut, on the other hand, requires a bit more effort to sharpen due to its high hardness. However, once sharpened, it retains the edge remarkably well.
Edge Retention
Edge retention signifies a steel’s ability to maintain its sharpness during use.
Both S45VN and Magnacut offer excellent edge retention due to their high carbon and vanadium content. Their balanced properties make them ideal for knives employed in frequent cutting tasks.
Price
S45VN, given its high-quality composition and performance, often comes at a higher price point. The cost is justified by its robust attributes and the state-of-the-art metallurgy process involved in its production.
Magnacut, while relatively new to the market, also demands a premium due to its unique balance of corrosion resistance, toughness, and edge retention.
Conclusion
Both S45VN and Magnacut stand as remarkable blade steels, each carrying their unique strengths and applications. S45VN is a sturdy, corrosion-resistant steel with excellent edge retention, making it suitable for general-purpose knives. Magnacut, with its exceptional balance of corrosion resistance, toughness, and edge retention, is ideal for knives expected to perform under high-stress conditions.
In the end, the choice between S45VN and Magnacut will depend on your knife’s intended use and your personal preference. Both steels represent outstanding choices for knives and are highly respected in the knife-making industry. It remains crucial to purchase from a reputable brand and manufacturer to fully utilize the potential of these steel types.
Do Sheepsfoot Blades Have A Purpose? (Cuz They’re Ugly…)
Spetsnaz Machetes – Blades Of The Russian Special Forces
What Is The Actual Purpose Of A Spear Point Knife Blade?
CRKT CEO Review – Coolest, Most Worthless Knife Ever?
How Sharp Is A Scalpel? (Is It Sharper Than A Razor?)
Can You Shave With A Knife? (Yes, Here’s How)
When you visit a merchant by clicking a link on this site we may make a commission on anything you buy (at no additional cost to you). Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to Amazon Associates and the eBay Partner Network.”