Elmax vs Magnacut – Battle of the Blade Steels

Sharing is caring!

---

~ At A Glance ~

ELMAX is a tough, wear-resistant steel that’s built for performance. It holds an edge for ages and shrugs off rust, but it can be a bit of a pain to sharpen and has a reputation for being a little chippy if pushed too hard.

Magnacut, on the other hand, is a newer steel that’s been turning heads for good reason. It’s got an impressive mix of edge retention, toughness, and corrosion resistance—and somehow manages to be easier to sharpen, too.

Both are excellent choices. But if you’re looking for a blade that’s easier to maintain, more forgiving under stress, and still delivers top-tier performance? Magnacut’s probably your best bet.

---

Top-Rated Knives

If you’ve spent any time looking into premium knife steels, you’ve probably seen ELMAX and Magnacut mentioned a lot—and for good reason. Both are high-performance steels used in serious blades, and both have their share of fans. But while they’re often mentioned in the same breath, they take very different approaches to performance.

ELMAX, made by Böhler-Uddeholm, has been around for a while. It’s known for combining excellent wear resistance, corrosion resistance, and edge retention into one reliable package. It’s what you might call a classic “super steel”—tough, proven, and capable.

Magnacut, on the other hand, is much newer. Developed by Larrin Thomas and produced by Crucible Industries, it was designed from the ground up to be optimized specifically for knives. The goal? A steel that’s hard, tough, stainless, and easy to sharpen—without having to compromise in any one area.

In the sections below, we’ll break down where these steels shine, where they fall short, and which one might make more sense for the way you use a knife.

Let’s get into it.

Steel Composition

Steel Composition

Let’s start with the building blocks. Here’s how ELMAX and Magnacut stack up on a chemical level:

Element	ELMAX	Magnacut
Carbon (C)	1.70%	1.15%
Chromium (Cr)	18.00%	12.75%
Molybdenum (Mo)	1.00%	0.75%
Vanadium (V)	3.00%	0.90%
Manganese (Mn)	0.30%	0.75%
Silicon (Si)	0.80%	0.60%
Nitrogen (N)	—	0.06%
Iron (Fe)	Balance	Balance

So What Does This Actually Mean?

So what does all that mean in plain English? ELMAX leans heavily on its high carbon and chromium content to deliver strong edge retention and excellent corrosion resistance. It also packs in a good amount of vanadium, which forms super-hard carbides that help the blade hold up to wear over time.

Magnacut, by contrast, takes a different approach. Even though it has less carbon and chromium on paper, it uses a finely tuned mix of elements to create a much more refined internal structure. It skips chromium carbides entirely, leaving more free chromium available to fight off rust—and blends in nitrogen to boost toughness without sacrificing performance. While both steels are impressive,

Magnacut was designed from the ground up to balance everything a knife steel needs: edge retention, corrosion resistance, toughness, and ease of sharpening. It’s not just versatile—it’s intentional.

ELMAX vs MAGNACUT – Complete Comparison

Hardness

Hardness

Hardness is one of the key players in how well a blade holds its edge and resists wear. It’s measured on the Rockwell Hardness Scale (HRC)—and the higher the number, the harder the steel.

Steel	Typical HRC Range	Notes
ELMAX	57–62 HRC	Excellent wear resistance; higher hardness means great edge holding, but a bit more prone to chipping at the upper end.
Magnacut	57–64 HRC	Offers impressive versatility—can be hardened for max edge retention or tempered for better toughness depending on the use case.

What It Means in Practice

• ELMAX is plenty hard for most cutting tasks and holds its edge very well. It’s happiest in that sweet spot around 60–61 HRC, where you get durability without too much brittleness.
• Magnacut brings something special to the table: it performs extremely well across a wider hardness range. Thanks to its powder metallurgy structure and dialed-in chemistry, it stays tough even when hardened up to 64 HRC—something most steels can’t pull off.

If you’re looking for a steel that can be tuned for different tasks—whether it’s slicing tomatoes or batoning wood—Magnacut takes the edge here.

Winner: Magnacut

Toughness

Toughness is a steel’s ability to resist cracking, chipping, or breaking when things get rough—like prying, batoning, or accidental drops. This is where some high-hardness steels struggle, but both ELMAX and Magnacut hold their own surprisingly well.

Steel	Toughness (relative)	Notes
ELMAX	Good	Tougher than many traditional stainless steels, but may chip under extreme lateral stress or hard impacts—especially when heat treated toward the higher end of its hardness range.
Magnacut	Excellent	Designed with a fine-tuned balance of carbon and vanadium to maximize toughness without giving up hardness or corrosion resistance. Performs exceptionally well even at 62+ HRC.

Real-World Takeaway

• ELMAX is impressively tough considering its high wear resistance, and for most uses—EDC, food prep, even light outdoor work—it’ll be just fine.
• But Magnacut takes things a step further, offering elite toughness that rivals or exceeds many carbon/tool steels like CPM-4V or A2, while still being fully stainless. It handles stress and abuse without flinching.

If you’re looking for a knife that can take a beating and keep on cutting—especially in field or survival settings—Magnacut wins this round hands-down.

Winner: Magnacut

Corrosion Resistance

Corrosion resistance is all about how well a steel can fight off rust, pitting, and oxidation—especially in humid, coastal, or wet environments where lesser steels can quickly get ugly.

Steel	Corrosion Resistance	Notes
ELMAX	Excellent	With around 18% chromium, ELMAX stands up well to moisture and kitchen use. It performs similarly to other stainless “super steels” like S35VN or M390.
Magnacut	Outstanding (Best-in-Class)	Despite having less chromium (~12.75%), Magnacut’s chemistry is optimized to completely avoid chromium carbides, leaving more free chromium in the matrix. This gives it corrosion resistance that rivals or exceeds marine-grade steels like LC200N or Vanax.

The Bottom Line

• ELMAX is definitely stainless and very capable in wet conditions—great for EDC or kitchen knives where corrosion resistance matters.
• Magnacut, however, is in a different league. Thanks to its finely tuned blend of chromium, nitrogen, and vanadium, it hits near-immunity to rust while still being high-performance steel. It’s arguably one of the most corrosion-resistant high-hardness steels available today.

If you want a worry-free blade that shrugs off saltwater, sweat, or humidity without constant oiling or babying:

Winner: Magnacut

Edge Retention & Sharpening Ease

These two traits often sit on opposite ends of the spectrum. The harder and more wear-resistant a steel is, the longer it holds an edge—but the tougher it can be to sharpen when it eventually dulls.

Steel	Edge Retention	Sharpening Ease	Notes
ELMAX	Excellent	Moderate–Hard	Thanks to its high hardness and dense vanadium carbide content, ELMAX holds an edge for a long time. But those same properties make it a bit stubborn to sharpen without diamonds or a guided system.
Magnacut	Excellent	Moderate–Easy	Despite similar hardness, Magnacut’s finer carbide structure and balanced design make it easier to maintain. It takes a keen edge without excessive effort and is less likely to resist sharpening over time.

Real-World Takeaway

• If you want a knife that stays sharp through long cutting sessions—think field dressing, rope work, or cardboard marathon—both steels deliver.
• But if you prefer something that’s a little easier to touch up between uses, Magnacut pulls ahead. It’s more responsive on stones and less likely to frustrate you if you’re not using powered sharpening gear.

Winner: Magnacut (slightly, due to its balance of edge retention and sharpening ease)

Price

LMAX has long held a reputation as a premium knife steel, and its pricing reflects that. You’ll typically find it in higher-end blades, often from European manufacturers or boutique production lines. It’s not outrageously priced, but it tends to sit in the upper tier, especially when paired with top-tier fit and finish.

Magnacut, while also a high-performance steel, is becoming more budget-friendly. When it first hit the market, prices were steep due to hype and limited supply. But as more mainstream brands adopt it, pricing has started to level out. These days, you can find Magnacut knives in both premium and mid-range categories, making it one of the most accessible “super steels” available right now.

Winner: Magnacut, for offering top-tier performance at a more approachable price point.

Conclusion

So, ELMAX vs. Magnacut—who wins?

Honestly? It depends. ELMAX is still a fantastic steel. It’s proven, it’s tough, and it’s built a solid rep for a reason. But if I’m being real, Magnacut kind of feels like cheating. It’s like someone looked at all the usual trade-offs in knife steel and just said, “No thanks.”

If you’re the kind of person who loves dialing in your edges and doesn’t mind a little extra sharpening effort, ELMAX will serve you well. But if you want something that holds up to abuse, shrugs off rust, and sharpens without a tantrum, Magnacut is just the easier choice.

At the end of the day, you’re not making a bad call either way. But if I had to pick one steel to use for everything? Yeah… I’m reaching for Magnacut.